The Leopard and the Lynx
Presented by FRIGID New York as part of The Queerly Festival 2026
Written and Directed by Michelle Maccarone
UNDER St Marks Theater, 94 St. Marks Place, in Manhattan
Monday June 22 7:00pm and Saturday June 27 1:00pm, 2026
Michelle Maccarone's The Leopard and The Lynx is inspired by the life of Patrick Dennis—the pseudonym of Pat Tanner III, whose irreverent 1955 novel Auntie Mame became one of the defining literary sensations of postwar America. Yet Maccarone wisely resists the familiar temptations of theatrical biography. Rather than chronicling Dennis' ascent to celebrity, she imagines an intimate reckoning between Pat and his estranged wife, Louise, at the moment their marriage begins to unravel under the unbearable weight of secrets neither history nor society would permit them to articulate openly. Having first appeared in the New York Theatre Festival before returning this June in the Queerly Festival, the play emerges as a deeply humane chamber drama that transforms historical fact into something more enduring: an examination of love tested by identity, and of two intelligent people struggling to remain compassionate as the truths they have long suppressed finally demand acknowledgment.
The setting is unmistakably the America of the 1960s, but Maccarone refuses to reduce that era to nostalgic décor or historical shorthand. Instead, she explores a society whose rigid expectations imprison nearly everyone within it. Pat's dawning acceptance of his bisexuality is only one strand of a larger meditation on the impossible bargains demanded by convention. Louise, too, finds herself constrained by a culture that celebrates feminine devotion while discouraging female autonomy. Their marriage becomes less the story of betrayal than of parallel acts of sacrifice, each partner surrendering essential parts of themselves in pursuit of a version of domestic happiness that proves tragically unsustainable. What begins as the collapse of a relationship gradually broadens into an eloquent inquiry into gender, marriage, feminism, and the painful distance between public performance and private truth.
The Leopard and The Lynx imagines the emotional fallout of a pivotal moment in Tanner's life, when his lover, Guy Kent, compels him to choose between maintaining the façade of a conventional family life and embracing his true identity. During a family vacation in Italy, Tanner makes the devastating decision to leave his wife and children to begin a life with Kent. Rather than treating the event as scandal or biography, the play explores the human cost of that choice, examining the competing claims of love, duty, authenticity, and social expectation in an era when living openly as a queer man often meant destroying the life one had painstakingly constructed. Through an intimate confrontation between Tanner and his estranged wife, Louise, Maccarone transforms a historical episode into a poignant meditation on identity, marriage, and the painful consequences of choosing truth over convention.
Maccarone's greatest strength lies in her refusal to manufacture villains. The Leopard and the Lynx is populated not by antagonists but by wounded adults whose competing loyalties make honesty feel almost impossible. Her dialogue unfolds with remarkable patience, allowing revelations to emerge naturally from conversations that initially seem ordinary before exposing years of accumulated disappointment, tenderness, and regret. The title itself evokes elusive predators whose instincts are shaped by caution and survival, and that metaphor quietly informs every exchange. The characters circle one another with the wary intelligence of creatures who understand that the deepest wounds are often inflicted unintentionally. It is an unusually literary script, trusting silence as much as speech and finding dramatic power in hesitation, implication, and the eloquence of what remains unsaid.
The production benefits enormously from a cast that embraces this emotional subtlety. As Pat Tanner III, Jere Williams delivers a beautifully restrained performance, revealing a man whose cultivated confidence continually gives way to flashes of profound vulnerability. Catherine Brophy is equally compelling as Louise, balancing fierce intelligence with heartbreaking generosity, refusing to let the character become merely the abandoned spouse. Matt Matros lends Julian Mueller a welcome intellectual steadiness, while Noah Chartrand's Guy Kent introduces a necessary volatility that unsettles the emotional equilibrium of every scene he enters. Bridget McJohn brings warmth and wit to Betsy Tanner without sacrificing emotional credibility, and Sarah Feldman's Patricia Kent quietly accumulates significance until she becomes an indispensable emotional witness to the family's unraveling. Together, the ensemble listens as intently as it speaks, creating performances that feel lived rather than performed.
Directing her own work, Maccarone displays uncommon confidence in theatrical restraint. She understands that emotional intensity rarely requires emphatic staging and instead allows stillness to become an expressive language of its own. Scenes breathe with an organic rhythm that privileges authentic human behavior over conspicuous dramatic punctuation. The production never strains for sentiment or easy catharsis, trusting both the actors and the audience to discover the emotional currents flowing beneath each carefully measured conversation. That confidence proves richly rewarding, producing a theatrical experience that grows more affecting with each successive revelation.
What distinguishes The Leopard and The Lynx most profoundly is its generosity of spirit. While rooted in the specific circumstances of Patrick Dennis and Louise Tanner, the play ultimately transcends biography to become a compassionate meditation on the ways identity is negotiated within love, family, and history itself. Maccarone understands that authenticity is seldom achieved through solitary acts of self-discovery; it is forged through painful conversations, imperfect forgiveness, and the willingness to acknowledge the complicated humanity of those who have shared our lives. In an era when queer stories are increasingly liberated from narratives of secrecy, The Leopard and The Lynx looks backward not to mourn what was lost but to illuminate the courage required simply to live honestly. Quietly devastating yet ultimately hopeful, it confirms Michelle Maccarone as a playwright of uncommon emotional intelligence, capable of finding profound theatrical resonance in the smallest gestures of compassion and the most fragile acts of truth.
Click HERE for tickets.
Review by Tony Marinelli.
Published by Theatre Beyond Broadway on July 14, 2026. All rights reserved.
